Back in the mid-2000s, a woman in Clearwater decided to teach her boyfriend a lesson after he kept leaving his truck unlocked. She thought it’d be funny to "steal" it as a prank and hide it around the corner. But Florida being Florida, a guy riding his bicycle happened to see the unlocked truck with the keys inside, thought he’d teach the owner a lesson, and decided to steal it for real.

The woman, now realizing the truck was actually gone, called the police to report it stolen—while leaving out the part about her prank. Meanwhile, the guy who stole the truck realized he wasn’t great at driving stick, stalled out, and abandoned it… in front of a donut shop. Of course, an officer enjoying his break spotted it, called it in, and the whole thing unraveled.

The boyfriend thought the whole ordeal was hilarious. The woman? Not so much when she had to explain it to the cops. The guy on the bike? He was arrested, but apparently, he said, "This is why I don’t prank people!" when they cuffed him. Total Florida chaos.